$8 Doorstep Delivery available to Indianapolis, Carmel, Fishers, Zionsville & Westfield
Sign up / Log in
Go to wishlist
Wish List
Toggle cart
Cart
Search
Gift Ideas
Holiday
All Holiday
Holiday: Ornaments
Holiday: Stationery
Holiday: Decor
Jewelry
All Jewelry
Local Designers
All Local Designers
Evan Knox Designs
Salame Jewelry Designs
Twigs and Twine
Birthstone Jewelry
All Birthstone Jewelry
Garnet - January's Birthstone
Amethyst - February's Birthstone
Aquamarine - March's Birthstone
Diamond - April's Birthstone
Emerald - May's Birthstone
Pearl - June's Birthstone
Ruby - July's Birthstone
Peridot - August's Birthstone
Sapphire - September's Birthstone
Opal and Tourmaline - October's Birthstones
Topaz and Citrine - November's Birthstones
Turquoise - December's Birthstone
Basics
Bracelets
Earrings
All Earrings
Dangle Earrings
Hoop Earrings
Stud Earrings
Necklaces
Pendants + Charms
Rings
Watches
Other Styling Accessories
Housewares
All Housewares
Candles + Bath
Entertaining Barware
Garden + Outdoors + Nature
Kitchen
All Kitchen
Coffee + Tea
Kitchen Accessories
Tasty Treats
Recipe Books
Mugs + Glassware
Office + Desktop
Prints + Star Lights + Other Decor
All Prints + Star Lights + Other Decor
Flags
Prints + Other Wall Decor
Star Lights
Trinket Tray + Jewelry Holder
Stationery
All Stationery
Calendars + Planners
Greeting Cards
Journals + Notebooks
Notepads + Sticky Notes
Pens + Pencils + Markers
Gift Bags + Wrapping Paper
Sustainable Goods + Living
Whatnot
All Whatnot
Apparel
All Apparel
Women's Socks
Men's Socks
TShirts
Cozy Knits
Bags + Zips + Totes
Books
Curious Oddities
Games + Puzzles
Health + Wellness
Kids
Stickers + Pins + Other Flair
All Stickers + Pins + Other Flair
Pins + Keychains + More
Stickers!
Indy Love
Gift Cards + Gift Boxes
All Gift Cards + Gift Boxes
Gift Cards
Pre-Made Gift Boxes
Group Gifting
Clearance
All Clearance
50% Off Select Items
50% Off Select Jewelry
About Us
All About Us
Our Story
Store Locations
It Takes a Team
Jobs at Silver in the City
Silver Linings Fund
All Silver Linings Fund
About Silver Linings Fund
Past Recipients
Open Application
Gift cards
Blog
Blogs
Sign up / Log in
Toggle search
Toggle search
Go to wishlist
Wish List
Toggle cart
Cart
Search
Shopping cart
Close cart panel
Your cart is currently empty
Home
/
Whatnot
/
Stickers + Pins + Other Flair
/
Pins + Keychains + More
Pins + Keychains + More
Show filters
19 products
Sort by
Default
Most viewed
Newest products
Lowest price
Highest price
Name ascending
Name descending
Grid view
List view
Add to wishlist
Patch Keychain
$9.00
More options
Add to wishlist
Air Freshener
$6.25
More options
Add to wishlist
And Here We Are Keychain
$16.00
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Vaccinated but Still Not A Hugger Pin
$2.00
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
I'm Vaccinated Keychain
$14.95
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
I'm Vaccinated Pin
$14.95
More options
Add to wishlist
Colorful Pronoun Pin
$2.50
More options
Add to wishlist
Indiana Heart Keychain
$7.95
More options
Add to wishlist
Heart Pronoun Pin
$10.00
Sale
Add to wishlist
Pet Tag & Keychain:
$8.12
$16.25
More options
Add to wishlist
RBG's Favorite Collar
$14.95
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Peace Hands Enamel Pin Set of 2
$20.00
Sale
Add to wishlist
Jólakötturinn (aka The Christmas Cat) Items
$13.00
$26.00
Add to wishlist
Ello There Sticky Patch
$6.25
More options
Add to wishlist
Indiana Heart Magnets
$6.95
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Trans and LGBTQ+ Pride Flag Combo Pin
$14.95
Sale
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
2016: How We Voted (and Didn’t Vote) Pin
$7.47
$14.95
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Vote! Round Vinyl Sticker
$3.00
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Feminist Enamel Pin
$9.95
Gift Ideas
Holiday
Jewelry
Housewares
Whatnot
Apparel
Bags + Zips + Totes
Books
Curious Oddities
Games + Puzzles
Health + Wellness
Kids
Stickers + Pins + Other Flair
Pins + Keychains + More
Stickers!
Indy Love
Gift Cards + Gift Boxes
Clearance
About Us
Please accept cookies to help us improve this website Is this OK?
Yes
No
More on cookies »