In-store pickup available in Indy and Carmel!
Sign up / Log in
Go to wishlist
Wish List
Toggle cart
Cart
Search
Gift Ideas
Jewelry
All Jewelry
Local Designers
All Local Designers
Evan Knox Designs
Salame Jewelry Designs
Twigs and Twine
Birthstone Jewelry
All Birthstone Jewelry
Garnet - January's Birthstone
Amethyst - February's Birthstone
Aquamarine - March's Birthstone
Diamond - April's Birthstone
Emerald - May's Birthstone
Pearl - June's Birthstone
Ruby - July's Birthstone
Peridot - August's Birthstone
Sapphire - September's Birthstone
Opal and Tourmaline - October's Birthstones
Topaz and Citrine - November's Birthstones
Turquoise - December's Birthstone
Basics
Bracelets
Earrings
All Earrings
Dangle Earrings
Hoop Earrings
Stud Earrings
Necklaces
Pendants + Charms
Rings
Watches
Other Styling Accessories
Housewares
All Housewares
Candles + Bath
Entertaining Barware
Garden + Outdoors + Nature
Kitchen
All Kitchen
Coffee + Tea
Kitchen Accessories
Tasty Treats
Recipe Books
Mugs + Glassware
Office + Desktop
Prints + Star Lights + Other Decor
All Prints + Star Lights + Other Decor
Flags
Prints + Other Wall Decor
Star Lights
Trinket Tray + Jewelry Holder
Stationery
All Stationery
Calendars + Planners
Greeting Cards
Journals + Notebooks
Notepads + Sticky Notes
Pens + Pencils + Markers
Gift Bags + Wrapping Paper
Sustainable Goods + Living
Whatnot
All Whatnot
Apparel
All Apparel
Women's Socks
Men's Socks
TShirts
Cozy Knits
Bags + Zips + Totes
Books
Curious Oddities
Games + Puzzles
Health + Wellness
Kids
Stickers + Pins + Other Flair
All Stickers + Pins + Other Flair
Pins + Keychains + More
Stickers!
Indy Love
Gift Cards + Gift Boxes
All Gift Cards + Gift Boxes
Gift Cards
Pre-Made Gift Boxes
Group Gifting
Clearance
All Clearance
50% Off Select Items
50% Off Select Jewelry
About Us
All About Us
Our Story
Store Locations
It Takes a Team
Jobs at Silver in the City
Silver Linings Fund
All Silver Linings Fund
About Silver Linings Fund
Past Recipients
Online Application
Gift cards
Blog
Blogs
Sign up / Log in
Toggle search
Toggle search
Go to wishlist
Wish List
Toggle cart
Cart
Search
Shopping cart
Close cart panel
Your cart is currently empty
Home
/
Whatnot
/
Stickers + Pins + Other Flair
/
Pins + Keychains + More
Pins + Keychains + More
Show filters
17 products
Sort by
Default
Most viewed
Newest products
Lowest price
Highest price
Name ascending
Name descending
Grid view
List view
More options
Add to wishlist
Patch Keychain
$10.00
More options
Add to wishlist
Air Freshener
$6.00
More options
Add to wishlist
And Here We Are Keychain
$16.00
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Vaccinated but Still Not A Hugger Pin
$2.00
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
I'm Vaccinated Keychain
$14.95
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
I'm Vaccinated Pin
$14.95
More options
Add to wishlist
Colorful Pronoun Pin
$2.50
More options
Add to wishlist
Indiana Heart Keychain
$7.95
More options
Add to wishlist
Heart Pronoun Pin
$10.00
Sale
More options
Add to wishlist
Pet Tag & Keychain:
$8.12
$16.25
More options
Add to wishlist
RBG's Favorite Collar
$14.95
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Peace Hands Enamel Pin Set of 2
$20.00
Sale
More options
Add to wishlist
Jólakötturinn (aka The Christmas Cat) Items
$12.00
$24.00
More options
Add to wishlist
Indiana Heart Magnets
$6.95
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Trans and LGBTQ+ Pride Flag Combo Pin
$14.95
Sale
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
2016: How We Voted (and Didn’t Vote) Pin
$7.47
$14.95
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Vote! Round Vinyl Sticker DNO
$3.00
Gift Ideas
Jewelry
Housewares
Whatnot
Apparel
Bags + Zips + Totes
Books
Curious Oddities
Games + Puzzles
Health + Wellness
Kids
Stickers + Pins + Other Flair
Pins + Keychains + More
Stickers!
Indy Love
Gift Cards + Gift Boxes
Clearance
About Us
Please accept cookies to help us improve this website Is this OK?
Yes
No
More on cookies »