Shipping & returns


Next Day In-store Pick-up: Give us a day and we will have your order ready to pick-up at our 434 Massachusetts Avenue store.  In a hurry?  Please give us a call at 317-955-9925 and let us know when you would prefer to pick-up your order.  Want to pick-up your order in Carmel?  Please mention that in the notes section of your order, or reply to the order confirmation email and allow an extra day for us to make sure it's in place and ready to go!

But if you’re not within driving distance of our store, here’s how it’s going to go down.

U.S. Orders
Our standard shipping methods are USPS Priority and UPS Ground shipping. If you choose an expediated shipping option, please know that your order will go out the next business day, thus adding one day to the shipping estimate (if you choose 2-day shipping on a Saturday, your order will go out on Monday and should be delivered Wednesday). Please note per the USPS, estimated dates of delivery are expected dates and not guaranteed.

International Orders
Please give us a shout at [email protected] if your country is not showing up as a viable shipping option.  In two shakes of a lambs tail, we'll work to get a shipping estimate to you and help you to complete your transaction.


Returns & Exchanges:

We want you to be 100% wowed by your purchase at Silver in the City, but we understand that sometimes, this just doesn't happen. If you are not completely happy with your purchase, please email us at [email protected] to let us know. Then return your item(s) to Returns, Silver in the City, 434 Massachusetts Avenue, Indianapolis, IN 46204 (we suggest using a shipping method with tracking). Once we receive your return, we will refund your original method of payment in the amount of the products returned (original shipping charges are non-refundable).

By using our website, you agree to the use of cookies. These cookies help us understand how customers arrive at and use our site and help us make improvements. Hide this message More on cookies »